10 Clear Reasons Why Muhammad Was Never a True Prophet of God

10 Clear Reasons Why Muhammad Was Never a True Prophet of God

By Dr. Maxwell Shimba

Throughout history, God’s true prophets have demonstrated integrity, holiness, compassion, and unwavering obedience to divine moral standards. From Noah to Moses, David to Isaiah — none ever violated the sacred laws they proclaimed. However, when we examine the character and actions of Muhammad through Islamic sources themselves, it becomes evident that he could not have been a true prophet of the living God. Here are ten undeniable reasons:

1. A Prophet of God Never Orders the Stoning of Others for Rejecting Him — But Muhammad Did.

Evidence: Ibn Ishaq, page 764
No prophet of God ever commanded the execution of those who disbelieved in him. They preached repentance and left judgment to God. Muhammad, however, ordered executions for disbelief.

---

2. A Prophet of God Would Never Marry the Wife of His Adopted Son — But Muhammad Did.

When Zayd, Muhammad’s adopted son, divorced his wife Zaynab, Muhammad married her — something no prophet of God ever permitted for themselves.
Qur'anic Reference: Surah Al-Ahzab 33:37

---

3. A Prophet Would Never Give a Woman as a Gift to Satisfy Another Man’s Desires — But Muhammad Did.

Proof: Sahih Al-Bukhari Vol. 1, Hadith 371
This act dehumanizes women, treating them as property — a practice never endorsed by any true prophet.

---

4. No Prophet Ever Violated the Sanctity of Family, Let Alone His Own Aunt — But Muhammad Did.

Proof: Kanz Al-Ummal, Hadith Chapter 13, Page 274
This shameful act stands in stark contradiction to the purity expected of a prophet.

---

5. A Prophet of God Would Never Slaughter Hundreds for Disbelief — But Muhammad Did.

Proof: Sahih Muslim Hadith 4390
Ordering the massacre of 800 men in a single night for not accepting his claim disqualifies him as a prophet of mercy.

---

6. A Prophet Would Never Order the Killing of a Woman for a Trivial Offense — But Muhammad Did.

Evidence: Ibn Ishaq, Pages 819 & 995
The sanctity of life — especially women — is upheld by all true prophets, yet Muhammad transgressed this repeatedly.

---

7. No Prophet Would Stone a Pregnant Woman Begging for Mercy — But Muhammad Did.

Proof: Sahih Muslim, Book 17, Hadith 4206
True prophets lead with mercy and redemption, not cruelty.

---

8. A Prophet Would Never Command Forced Conversions or Kill Those Who Refuse — But Muhammad Did.

Proof: Surah At-Tawbah 9:5
This command alone exposes the violent expansionist nature of early Islam, a sharp contrast to Biblical prophets.

---

9. No Prophet Would Keep and Use Sex Slaves — But Muhammad Did.

Despite having numerous wives, Muhammad kept and used sex slaves, a violation of God’s moral laws regarding human dignity.

---

10. No Prophet Would Marry a Child and Consummate the Marriage at Nine — But Muhammad Did.

Proof: Sahih Muslim, Hadith 3309
This act alone invalidates any claim to divine moral authority.

---

Final Warning and Invitation

If you still believe in this man as God’s messenger after knowing these facts from Islamic sources themselves, understand that you are embracing what God condemns.
The God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob — and the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ — would never send such a man. The earlier you accept Jesus Christ, the true and sinless Son of God, the better. He alone lived without sin, gave His life as a ransom for all, and rose again for our justification.

Reject deception. Choose eternal life. Accept Jesus today.

---