A Scientific and Rational Challenge to Sahih Muslim 2643b

In Sahih Muslim 2643b, it is narrated that the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) said:

"There is no disease that Allah has created, except that He also has created its treatment."

At first glance, this sounds optimistic — but let's test it against modern medical science and observable reality.

Scientific Refutation:

If every disease truly had a cure created by Allah, why do countless diseases remain incurable even in the 21st century?
What about:

• HIV/AIDS — no definitive cure, only management therapies.

• Cancers — many types remain terminal and uncurable.

• Neurodegenerative diseases — like Alzheimer’s and ALS, with no known cure.

• Genetic disorders — like Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy or Huntington's Disease, irreversible and fatal.

If Allah created cures for these, where are they?
Humanity has been relentlessly searching through science, yet millions still die painfully each year.

Theological Question:

If Allah, as per Islamic belief, is All-Knowing and All-Merciful, why withhold those cures for millennia while millions suffer?
What kind of divine justice or mercy is this?
And what does it say about Muhammad's prophethood if such claims, stated as divine truths, collapse under empirical scrutiny?

In contrast, Jesus Christ didn’t make medical claims — He healed supernaturally, instantly curing the blind, the paralyzed, and even raising the dead, as verified in multiple eyewitness accounts (Mark 5:41-43, John 11:43-44).

Moreover, the Bible never pretends that every disease has an earthly cure — it acknowledges the fallen nature of humanity and offers eternal life in a perfect, healed world through Christ.

So, dear reader: who truly speaks with divine authority?

• A prophet whose sayings fail under modern evidence?

• Or the sinless, miracle-working Jesus Christ, whose words and power transcend time and science?

The choice is yours.

#TruthTested #ScienceVsHadith #JesusIsLord

---