The Discrepancies Between Allah and Muhammad: A Doctrinal Dilemma

The Discrepancies Between Allah and Muhammad: A Doctrinal Dilemma

By Dr. Maxwell Shimba | Shimba Theological Institute

One of the most troubling aspects of Islamic theology, which rarely receives open scrutiny, is the glaring contradiction between what Allah supposedly decrees in the Qur’an and what Muhammad later commands through hadith literature. This theological discord reveals a disturbing inconsistency within Islam’s foundations — an inconsistency believers deserve to examine honestly.

The attached chart highlights some of these contradictions:

1. The Number of Daily Prayers

• Allah’s command: Muslims are instructed to pray three times a day (Qur'an 24:58).

• Muhammad’s command: Later, Muhammad increases it to five times a day (Sahih al-Bukhari 528).

If Allah’s word is perfect and eternal, why would Muhammad alter a direct divine command?

---

2. The Right of Intercession

• Allah states: All intercession belongs to Him alone (Qur'an 39:44).

• Muhammad claims: He has been granted the exclusive right of intercession on Judgment Day (Sahih al-Bukhari 335).

This is a bold contradiction. If no one can intercede but Allah, how does Muhammad assume a privilege denied to all creation?

---

3. Mut’a (Temporary Marriage)

• Allah permits it: Qur'an 33:51 allows temporary marriages.

• Muhammad cancels it: Later abrogated by Muhammad in Sahih al-Bukhari 5523.

Did God change His mind, or did Muhammad override divine permission?

---

4. Laws Regarding Slave Women

• Allah decrees: Slave women must observe a waiting period after separation (Qur'an 4:24).

• Muhammad contradicts: Declares no waiting period is necessary (Sahih al-Bukhari 2235).

This inconsistency highlights the moral and doctrinal confusion embedded in Islamic jurisprudence.

---

The Theological Implications

These contradictions suggest that Muhammad often revised, altered, or overruled Quranic declarations for situational convenience. This is not merely a matter of differing interpretations but direct conflicts between Allah’s supposedly eternal decrees and Muhammad’s evolving rulings.

For Christians, this underscores the reliability and consistency of the Gospel message. In contrast to Islam’s shifting commands, the New Testament reveals a Savior whose word is unchanging and whose authority is absolute.

As Hebrews 13:8 declares:

“Jesus Christ is the same yesterday and today and forever.”

---

Conclusion:
This doctrinal tug-of-war between Allah and Muhammad is a fatal flaw within Islamic theology — exposing it as a man-made system rather than a divine revelation. It’s time for seekers of truth to reevaluate Islam’s claims in light of these undeniable inconsistencies and consider the unchanging truth of Jesus Christ.

---